As decided by who had a top 3 biggest edit episode-by-episode.
EPISODE 1 - Nick Wilson (1), Christian Hubicki (1), and Dan Rengering (1)
EPISODE 2 - Christian Hubicki (2), Natalie Cole (1), and Lyrsa Torres (1)
EPISODE 3 - Natalie Cole (2), Jeremy Crawford (1), and Bi Nguyen (1)
EPISODE 4 - Elizabeth Olson (1), Natalia Azoqa (1), and Alec Merlino (1)
EPISODE 5 - Angelina Keeley (1), Natalie Cole (3), and Nick Wilson (2)
EPISODE 6 - Angelina Keeley (2), Mike White (1), and Lyrsa Torres (2)
EPISODE 7 - Angelina Keeley (3), Alec Merlino (2), and Dan Rengering (2)
EPISODE 8 - Nick Wilson (3), Mike White (2), and Angelina Keeley (4)
EPISODE 9 - Kara Kay (1), Alison Raybould (1), and Alec Merlino (3)
EPISODE 10 - Christian Hubicki (3), Alec Merlino (4), and Nick Wilson (4)
EPISODE 11 - Mike White (3), Angelina Keeley (5), and Carl Boudreaux (1)
EPISODE 12 - Christian Hubicki (4), Nick Wilson (5), and Gabby Pascuzzi (1)
EPISODE 13 - Davie Rickenbacker (1), Mike White (4), and Kara Kay (2)
EPISODE 14 (FINALE) - Angelina Keeley (6), Mike White (5), and Nick Wilson (6)
Castaways who starred in ZERO episodes:
Pat Cusack
Jessica Peet
John Hennigan
Castaways who starred in ONE episode:
Jeremy Crawford
Bi Nguyen
Natalia Azoqa
Elizabeth Olson
Carl Boudreaux
Gabby Pascuzzi
Davie Rickenbacker
Alison Raybould
Castaways who starred in TWO episodes:
Lyrsa Torres
Dan Rengering
Kara Kay
Castaways who starred in THREE episodes:
Natalie Cole
Castaways who starred in FOUR episodes:
Alec Merlino
Christian Hubicki
Castaways who starred in FIVE episodes:
Mike White
Castaways who starred in SIX episodes:
Angelina Keeley
Nick Wilson
Given these stats, the Star of David vs. Goliath was a tie between Angelina and our winner, Nick. Honorable mentions to Mike White, Christian Hubicki, and Alec Merlino. Purple Awards go out to Pat, Jessica, and John.