Here's how my process will work: first off, eliminate the premerge game altogether. In my eyes, the premerge is the regular season, and it leads up to the real deal; the postmerge. So automatically, the 10 people who never participated in a merge vote are already ruled out: Fairplay, Yau-Man, Mikey B, Joel, Penner, Chet, Kathy, Tracy, Ami, and some other lady. For each round of the merge, I'm going to give a point to half of the castaways (for odd numbers I will round down, for example, I'll give 4 people points out of the final 9) I will continue this through the finals. Whoever has the most points will be survivornerd's Player of the Season!
FINAL 10
Jason, Eliza, and Ozzy are ruled out for either voting incorrectly or receiving votes. Alexis is also ruled out for being seen as too close to Ozzy by Amanda, and Parvati is ruled out for upsetting Amanda by pledging her allegiance without her consent. Amanda, Cirie, Natalie, Erik, and James each gain a point.
FINAL 9
Parvati, Cirie, Natalie, and Alexis each gain a point for voting correctly and not receiving a vote.
FINAL 8
Jason, James, and Parvati are all ruled out for receiving votes. Natalie gains a point for convincing Jason that he was safe. Erik gains a point for winning immunity. Amanda gains a point for being angry with Parvati and Cirie, but managing to keep it to herself. Alexis gains the last point over Cirie because Amanda was upset with Cirie.
FINAL 7
Amanda gains a point for getting sent to Exile, where she found the idol clue. Cirie and Natalie also gain points for getting taken on the reward.
FINAL 6
Parvati and Amanda gain points for voting correctly. Erik receives a point for winning immunity.
FINAL 5
Erik and Parvati are ruled out for receiving votes. Cirie gains a point for having people come to her to vent and helping convincing Erik he needed redemption from the jury. Amanda gains the last point for getting taken on the reward, and not getting as angry as Natalie was.
FINAL 4
Parvati and Amanda are the only two to not receive votes, gaining them a point.
FINAL 3
Amanda gains a point for winning the final immunity and ousting Cirie.
FINAL 2
Parvati gains a point for beating Amanda.
NOW, time for the rankings...
.
.
.
.
10. Eliza Orlins - 0 points
9. Ozzy Lusth - 0 points
8. Jason Siska - 0 points
7. James Clement - 1 point
6. Alexis Jones - 2 points
5. Erik Reichenbach - 3 points
4. Natalie Bolton - 4 points
3. Cirie Fields - 4 points
2. Parvati Shallow - 4 points
1. Amanda Kimmel - 7 points
Holy moly, for the second straight season, Amanda Kimmel is our Player of the Season! Greatest to never win? Natalie is the top Favorite. The Favorites garnered 16 total points compared to the Fans' 9.
