With Cambodia being such an amazing season, I think it is only a matter of time before we get another one.
Ken McNickle: He was in Millenials vs. Gen X but his playstyle was very much akin to old school Survivor. He made it to the final 3 but his playing style was seen as a fault. Him getting a second chance would allow him to change his style or align himself with some old school players.
Neal Gottlieb: He was in Kaoh Rong and was medically evacuated right after the merge. He was allowed on the jury but was unable to vote due to Michelle Fitzgerald. Overall, he deserves a second chance more than anyone else in recent seasons.
Donathon Hurley: From Ghost Island, he became synonymous with the truth bombs he would dish out at tribal. He made it far but could not overcome Dom and Wendell once they had the numbers and an inactive cast would not make a move against them due to them having advantages.
Stephanie Johnson: A premerge boot from Ghost Island who was a player, unlike most the cast in her respective season. She deserves another chance and she was someone who I thought had the potential to win the season if she had made it to the merge.
R.C. Saint-Amour: Maybe she can be convinced to come back since Abi won't be on the ballot this time? She was voted out in Philippines due to crappy numbers.
Josh Canfield/Reed Kelly: I am not sure if both of this pair should be brought back from San Juan Del Sur or just one? They were both entertaining and strong players trapped in the bottom.
David Samson: The first person voted out of Cagayan. He had the potential to be an entertaining Survivor but due to a bad first impressions decision and a dumpster fire Brains tribe the odds were against him.
COMMENT PEOPLE YOU THINK NEED A SECOND CHANCE, These are players who have played only once but did not win.
lionsden121 I was thinking that but didn't know if anyone would share the same sympathies. I don't even know if you're being ironic or not. He does have a good second chance story though and I think he would be open to playing again.
what are your thoughts on Michelle Schubert, Erinn Lobdell, and Ashley Underwood returning? I agree with your list that they deserve second chances (though i don't like all of them per se), but those 3 are definitely at the top of my list
blujay112 what seasons were they in? I am fairly new to Survivor? I started with Philippines and stopped when I was 12 but have recently started bingeing it. I have seen Philippines, Cagayan, San Juan Del Sur, Worlds Apart, Cambodia, Kaoh Rong, and I am watching Millennials vs Gen X.
