This site uses cookies. If you continue to browse the site, we shall assume that you accept the use of cookies.
Big Brother and online Hunger games.

Survivor Winner Play-through 1 (Brantsteele)

Mar 22, 2016 by mistiksaint
I had an idea for a blog series, I am going to take every survivor winner and put them into a simulation on Brant Steele replacing that seasons.

I will replace the winner of every season with Richard hatch and see how well he does and if he wins again. If he wins I will talk about how he did it and if he loses I will talk about how he lost and who won instead. If a situation like all stars happens where he was already on the cast but not the winner, then I will replace the real winner, amber in this case, with Shambo every time.

I will post in the comments, his placement in the seasons for those who are interested and to conserve space.

Play Through 1: Whole lotta Hatch

Comments

Borneo Replay: On his original winning season he didn’t win but he did come pretty damn close. He made it to the F3 with Sonja and Joel (wtf lol) where Sonja won her 5th individual immunity challenge. Sonja then won the FIC and took Joel with her to the FTC where she won in a 6-1 vote.
3rd
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
TAO Replay: Richard got 12th, Ogakor was split straight down the middle 4-4 and in a world post Marquesas they would have went to rocks but instead Jerri lost the tie breaker challenge and she went home, putting Richards alliance down in the numbers for the remainder of the premerge until he was voted off in 12th place. Kimmi Kappenburg wins by a 7-0 vote over Nick Brown, after the merge when Kucha had numbers there was a simple pagonging of Ogakor which culminated in a Kimm/Nick/Deb FIC where Kimmi won her 3rd individual immunity and voted out Deb securing a 7-0 vote to win.
12th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Africa Replay: Richard gets his first win by a vote of 6-1 over Frank. Richard got lucky pre swap and his side of the Boran alliance won out in a deadlock tie, then once the swapped happened they formed a solid 5 person alliance on New-Boran (2 original boran, 3 original Samburu) that would make the merge intact. Once they made the merge, original Boran voted with the new Boran alliance and took out the Non New-Boran Samburu members. After that New-Boran took out the non New-Boran original Boran members and New Boran was the F5. From there Richard won 3 straight immunities and voted out his original Boran tribe mate Jesse Comacho at the F3 to go on to win 6-1 over Frank.
1st
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Marquesas Replay: Richard gets 4th place in Marquesas and I’m not really quite sure how. He merged with a 6-4 advantage but the 6 person group split into 2 groups of 3 and only he and Peter Harkey made it far in the post merge where Peter ultimately beat Tammy and Zoe in the FIC and went on to win 6-1 over Zoe at FTC.
4th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Thailand Replay: Richard gets 5th place miraculously after being on the wrong side of a rock draw not one not two but 3 times throughout this season, he had some well-timed immunity wins that certainly did wonders for his safety but 5th is still 5th. The FIC ended up being Stephanie Dill vs Ghandia vs Clay Jordan, and once Stephanie won she was voted out clay and went on to win 5-2. Her biggest move was really luck when her alliance won a rock draw but none the less, she made it.
5th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
LOL @ Shambo

but the real question is, how realistic are you going to make it?
Like is it just all going to be random? or are you going to fill out profiles, have accurate relationships, accurate alliances, etc?
Sent by DumbGinger,Mar 22, 2016
dumbginger its going to be completely random. I've already done all of hatch and I'll try to do like one winner per day
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Amazon Replay: I thought Richard being on the womens tribe would be a challenge for him but apparently not. The women made the merge with a 6-4 advantage and I saw them vote out 3 of their own back to back losing the numbers and earning Richard a 5th place finish.  The FIC challenge ended up being Dave vs Ryan Aiken vs Matt, where Dave won and voted out Ryan. Dave then went on to win 5-2 over Matt and win survivor Amazon. So far everyone to win FIC has won the game.
5th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Pearl Islands Replay: Richard started off on a bad foot in Pearl Islands on a minority alliance and he ended up being the 13th place finished in a season of 16, his worst performance to date. There was no outcast twist, and the Drake tribe was able to pagong the morgan tribe following a rock draw at the merge. After that Trish vs Michelle vs Christa was the FIC and Trish was able to win, she voted out Christa and went on to be the first unanimous winner in this breakdown.
14th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
All Stars Replay: Since Richard was already competing in this season I will be replacing Amber with SHHHHAMBO because well, Shambo. Richard got 12 place because of the Chapera dissolve that left them in the minority on their own tribe. Chapera only lost 1 challenge and it was the challenge that dissolved them, thankfully for them that ment they had majority on both new tribes and were able to merge with majority. F3 ended up being Boston Rob vs Alicia vs Sue Hawk for FIC and Sue won immunity and voted out Alicia. Rob ended up winning by a vote of 5-2 and being the first person in this series to win the game without winning the FIC.
12th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Vanuatu Replay: In 17th place was Richard, he started off on the wrong foot again and I don’t know why. After so many strong seasons in the beginning its like he is losing his touch. The women pagonged the men like they were always destined to and the F3 ended up Dolly, Lisa Keiffer and Eliza. Dolly won the FIC and voted out Lisa where she went on to lose by a vote of 5-2 to the one and only Eliza
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Palau Replay: First boot, its all uphill from here rich. 18th place. At least you got picked for a team though. Koror was able to take out the Ulong tribe because they merged with numbers but they were not able to win every challenge like IRL. The f3 ended up Bobby Jon – Gregg – Willard (Ik Bobby J wasn’t Koror but Brant redoes the draft and everything) where Gregg won the FIC and voted out Bobby Jon, he then went on to beat Willard 6-1 at FTC.
18th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Guatemala Replay: Richard got 12th place for some reason. He was in the majority alliance and the rest of his allies made it very far in the game but he decided to get in a fight with everyone and was immediately voted out. Maybe he is cranky from doing 11 seasons of survivor. The rest of Richards alliance merged with the numbers, pagonged the other tribe and then went to the f3 with Brandon Jim and Brooke, Jim managed to win the FIC where he took Brandon to the end and lost in a 6-1 vote.
12th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Panama Replay: Richard got 9th and was the first member of the jury, there wasn’t much that could be done since Cirie found the god idol on day 1. The F3 ended up being Bob Dawg, Cirie, and Courtney where Courtney won her 5th straight immunity and took Bob Dawg to the FTC. At FTC, I never thought I would say this in a million years, Courtney Merit won 7-0 and was the sole survivor of Panama.
9th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Cook Islands Replay: Richard got 9th place, he was the first boot after the merge for being unlikeable. Will the Hatch ever rise to the top again? Who knows. Flicka was on a tribe that was completely decimated down until she was the very last person but she found a god idol and she kept on winning challenges and she persevered and made the F3 with Cecilia and Stephanie Favor. Unfortunately the jury didn’t like an underdog story and Cecilia won 8-1-0 with Flicka in 3rd.
9th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Fiji Replay: Richard gets 13th place on a purple rock draw, not much that can be done there. The Ravu tribe wins nearly every challenge but collapse at the merge allowing Yau and Alex to skate by to the very end at the F3. The F3 ended up being Sylvia Yau man and Alex and shocking to everyone Sylvia wins 6-2-1 winning all of her votes at the jury questions.
13th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
China Replay: Richard was r.obbed, he got 2nd place but he played by far the best game of the season. Going from a minority alliance on his original tribe to winning every challenge pre twist and then playing a successful idol at the merge to put his alliance up when it was 5-5, and winning 3 individual immunities. He made it to the end with James and Leslie Nease and Leslie beat him by a vote of 5-2-0.
2nd
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Micronesia Replay: Richard didn’t do so well, he was in the majority on his original tribe but after the swap the people on the bottom flipped and the favorites started taking each other out. Once the favorites got to the merge they were down 6-4 and then the fans started to implode, and the favorites somehow made it to the f4 all together without any idols. At the F3 were penner, james and Ami and when james won his 4th individual immunity he vote out penner and went on to win 5-3 against Ami.
12th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Gabon Replay:  Richard got 10th and was the 1st juror, after the swap he was literally the only person from his original tribe on the new tribe so as soon as they lost a challenge he was voted off. The season then continued to be madness until Randy, Charlie and Paloma ended up as the F3. Paloma then impressed a lot of people at FTC and won in a 5-1-1 vote.
10th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Tocantins Replay: First boot, picked the wrong side of the numbers. Was a fool. The winner of the season was on Tambira and they had a majority post merge, they ended up pagonging Jalapau and then once it got down to the f5 of them, she was no longer in the majority. She won 3 straight immunity challenges, and the FIC was between Tai Carolina and Spencer, where Carolina finished the job and won her final immunity challenge and voted out Tai. She took big FTC goat Spencer with her and won handily 6-1.
16th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Samoa Replay: Richard and his Foa Foa 6 got taken down by the Galu 4, it was almost comical. Nevertheless his great social game got him to be the last Foa Foa member voted off, and 5th place. On the other side Yasmin found 3 idols, won 3 challenges and ultimately beat out Kelly S. and Laura M. for the title of sole survivor in a 5-2-2 vote.
5th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Heros vs Villains Replay: Richard went out very early premerge on a villains tribe that lost nearly every single challenge and only merged with 3 people. From the merge on All of the Villains were taken out except Coach he clawed his way to the F3 with James and JT, despite not having a single other villain in the game for 6 tribal councils in a row. Coach Won the FIC and went to the end with JT and James, getting 3rd place in a 6-2-1 vote where JT won.
17th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Nicaragua Replay: Rich was the first boot at the merge because this season was a mess, there were never any long term alliances and the older people would flip on themselves and the younger would flip on themselves left and right. It was madness, but in the end Tyrone went UTR and didn’t piss as many people off as his OTT opponents at FTC, Shannon Elkins and Yve who had 3 idols, so he won in a 7-2-0 vote with Yve getting 2nd.
12th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Redemption Island Replay: Richard was voted out in the premerge after starting off on the wrong side of the numbers, he was able to deflect the target onto his allies and third parties for a while but eventually there was no where left to hide and he was the last one. Then the zapatera majority of 6 at the merge pagonged everyone and when it was time to get rid of their own they voted off Julie who went to redemption island and won, came back in won 2 immunities and sat in the finals with David and Kristina Klumpp where she won the closest FTC yet by a vote of 4-3-2.

14th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
South Pacific Replay: Hatch doesn’t do so hot on seasons with RI in play, he goes out 3rd but he loses his RI round and so he is eliminated 2nd. Savaii merged with numbers and then pagonged all of Upolu and the only person who lasted for any amount of time was Christina who was voted out at the f5, twice. Papa Bear ended up finding and playing 3 idols as well was winning 2 individual immunities that propelled him over Ozzy and Dawn in a 6-3-0 vote where Dawn got 2nd.
17th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
One World Replay: This one made me sad, he was going to win and he got med evaced at the f4 with his 2 closest allies in the game. Rich had a cross tribe alliance with Colton and Jonas and the 3 of them were able to take down an 8 person alliance with idols and arguments. Once they got to the f4, Richard got med evaced when Bill was supposed to go home. Colton went on to win 8-1-0 with Bill getting 2nd.
4th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Philippines Replay: Got 12th place and outsmarted by Angie of all people. I have no real comments on that. After Kalabaw’s 4 were split up like Matsing’s 2 IRL they did the exact same thing, they went to 2 different tribes and played both sides and ended up the final 4 of Kent, Penner, Carter and Katie. Katie was alone the entire game and she won her 3rd individual immunity to go to FTC where she beat Kent and Carter in an 6-1-1 vote
12th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Caramoan Replay:  Rich got blindsided with an idol in his pocket assuming the pagonging of the fans was going to continue just like it had been. But it didn’t Eddie got in good with all the favorites, as the last fan, and he rode that out all the way to the f3 where he had to play an idol and win 3 immunities to get there but he made it. Once he sat in the f3 with Erik and Phillip I thought he would win but NO, it was a tie 3-3-2 between Philip and Erik. The people who voted for Eddie changed their votes and Phillip was the winner of Caramoan.
10th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Blood vs Water Replay: Richard is the first boot again, he is eliminated during the first impressions twist and he loses to Gervase and Rupert in the first RI. Once the merge hits a couples alliance of Hayden/Kat Brad/Monica and Vytas/Aras take the numbers and slowly pick off everyone else. Once they are down to the f6 it is hayden vs caleb vs kat in the final RI Kat wins and comes back. She must decide between Brad/Monica and Vytas/Aras when Vytas gets very close with Kat and she decides to vote out Brad. The new final 3 is Vytas Aras and Kat and Vytas wins for his big move in swinging Kat in a 5-2-1 vote with Kat in 2nd place.
20th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Cagayan Replay: Richard was voted out early for being on the wrong side of the numbers on the original tribes. Once the swap happened the 4 remaining brawn team members teamed up with David Samson and took out the beauty tribe. And then at the merge they took out the brain tribe and were the final 5, once they were the final 5 david won 2 immunities at the end to sit next to trish and win 8-1.
15th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
San Juan Del Sur Replay: Richard went home early yet again for starting off on the wrong side of the numbers. Once they merged the hunapu people had numbers and their couples joined them and they voted off all of the single players. When it was at the F7 it was 3 pairs and John Rocker and he slipped past Alec/Drew and made it to the F5 and then from there he outlasted Baylor and Made the f4 and went to fire but lost to reed. The F3 ended up being Missy Reed and Josh where missy won 5-2-1 over Reed in 2nd.
17th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Worlds Apart Replay: Rich went early in the merge and it was his own fault. He had numbers and he was in a good position but he got into a huge fight with his own alliance mate and they lost the numbers. In one of the most comical wins I’ve ever seen Will wins 8-0-0. I won’t even really explain it, essentially he was the exact opposite as IRL, he won a ton of challenges and he was friends with everyone and never received a vote.
11th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
Second Chances Replay: Rich went home early merge, he was never really aligned with the majority he was just voting with them and so once there were no more options they got rid of him. All of the swaps made it very flexible in the game and the f7 were from the final version of Bayon. Ultimately they ended up with Shirin/ Wiggles/ Kass in the f3, where shirin won 9-1-0 with wiggles in 2nd place.
9th
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
I know that was a lot of posts and I am open to feedback and trying any ideas to make it better
Sent by mistiksaint,Mar 22, 2016
2 for 32 ain't bad
Sent by survivornerd,Mar 22, 2016
Post each one on an individual blog of their own - but it was good.
Sent by me2013,Mar 29, 2016

Leave a comment