With the announcement of All Stars 5 and its cast I would like to share my choices if I was to cast RPDR All Stars 6
Season 1:
Nina Flowers- Such a fierce queen who slayed her original season all the way back in season 1. Gave us some killer looks on the runway, aswell as a very unique aesthetic and makeup style. Another queen who was screwed over by the All Stars 1 format as she was doomed after pairing up with Tammie. I would love to see her compete again and see what she still got
Season 2:
Tatianna- Ok I understand she was already cast on All Stars 2, however, all the fans and production, including Rupaul, her elimination was bullshit. She didnt get a chance to show off her new and improved skills on AS2 because of the Rolaskatox flex. I would love to see her comeback and prove that she really has got what it takes to win.
Season 4:
Willam- Probably, one of the most hyped and wanted queens to be on All Stars. She did really well in Season 4 and was eliminated because she broke the rules that didnt actually affect them, in terms of competition. She is such a big fan favourite and has changed so much. She would also bring a lot of drama to the season and I could see her making seriously shady game moves.
Season 5:
Ivy Winters- The only Miss Congeniality to not compete on 2 seasons of drag race. Shes not a huge fan favourite and we havent seen in a while, however it would be interesting to see how her drag has changed and her style and see how she is in the competitive environment again. She done quite well in her season and brought some gorgeous iconic looks (them stilts) and I think she would be like the Hero of the season because of how nice she is.
Season 8:
Kimchi- I think I heard that she declined All-Stars and doesnt want to compete on another competitive season of drag race. However, I would still love to see her on all stars. A lot of people say she deserved the crown over Bob (which I personally dont agree with), however I could see her taking the All-Stars crown. She is so mf funny and a big fan favourite and has some amazing makeup skills. She would definitely be one of the front runners of the season and would bring so many iconic Kimchi moments and memes.
Season 9:
Peppermint- Was a part of probably one of the Top/Strongest Top 4's in history of drag race. Such a role model and a spokesperson for the LGBTQIA+ community. I remember thinking I wouldnt like her on season 9, however her personality shone through and she was a lip sync ASSASSIN, to say the least. She won one of the most iconic drag race lip syncs in history and made the Season 9 final 2 when all odds were stacked against her (in terms of track record).
Season 10:
Asia O'Hara- She was a part of one of the biggest gags in drag race history aka Fluttergate, as I like to call it. She brought so many great looks to her season and competed very well and I love her personality. Like Peppermint, she is such a hero for the drag/gay community and is such a caring queen when it comes to others, as it showed on Season 10. Again, she is a queen who could create so many memes for the show after her murderous lip sync in the finale.
Season 11:
Brooke Lynn Hytes- Absolutely killed Season 11 and was the outright front runner and set to win, however she couldnt keep up with Yvie's head ruveal in the final lip sync which sealed her fate. So frigging talented and well rounded: she can dance, she can improv, she serves LOOKS and is a huge fan favourite after Season 11. And yet again, is a queen who took part in one of the most memorable lip syncs in drag race herstory.
Plastique Tiara- Represents the young drag queens and the modern style of drag and makeup and is a huge social media queen. She brought some gorgeous looks to Season 11 and has such a beautiful mug. She also backs this up as she can pull out some stunts in lip syncs. Yet again, another huge fan favourite and could bring some drama as she was labelled as a liar and shady by some queens on her season.
Scarlett Envy- Probably one of the most robbed queens on a normal season of drag race. She knows she cant dance however she put on such a show in that lip sync against Rajah and held her own. She was looked at as an underdog at the start of season 11, however she managed to snatch a win early on in the season and proved she is a great actor. To me, out of all the queens listed she is probably one of the weaker and one of the ones who didnt compete aswell on their season, however I'd like to see have a second chance and compete with the top dogs in the show.
I didnt include any Season 12 queens, because its still running, however Ill include some in the alternates
Alternates:
Season 5- Lineysha Sparx
Season 6- Trinity K Bonet, April Carrion
Season 8- Acid Betty
Season 9- Alexis Michelle
Season 10- Kameron Michaels
Season 11- A'keria C. Davenport, Nina West
Season 12- Heidi N Closet, Jan
