I was thinking that I really wanted to see who people thought sang each song the best on American Idol throughout all the seasons since there is so many that have been sung more than once and a few that have been sung multiple times. I'm gonna start from Season 11 and go backwards from there. If new songs come up throughout the weeks of the show, I'll put those up before I continue with the process backwards through the seasons.
The song that I'm doing for the first duel is the song that was sung this week by Erika Van Pelt which was received well by the judges but on the results night, it unfortunately ended in her elimination from American Idol. The song is New York State Of Mind by Billy Joel. The contestant that has performed this song before that Erika is going to be compared to is Kimberley Locke from Season 2.
Vote whichever one you think is better by posting that contestant's name in the comments below.
