Winners:
Danni, JT, Natalie, Sandra, & Tony I am okay with seeing return, but I don't care to se Earl return. I honestly think that he is only casted because he is a minority. However I would have preferred to see Mike return over Earl, but if Survivor really wanted a minority male winner to return then bring back Todd Herzogg (Gay) or Yul Kwon (Asian).
Jurors:
Andrea, Cirie, Malcolm, and Tai I am okay with seeing return, but I don't care to see Hali return.
My problem with Hali:
I believe Hali could have Parvati Micronesia upside, but Cirie is on the season and she seen that before. I would have taken personally Natalie Bolton everyday of the week over Hali. The fact that Natalie was so close to being on Heroes vs. Villains & the Second Chance ballot make me upset that she keeps getting passed over by others like Danielle DiLorenzo or Monica Padilla and now Hali Ford. If you don't want Natalie Bolton for whatever reason then you have Carolyn Rivera or Sarah Lacina. I would believe both of those women would have kicked as on this season. Besides the fact that Carolyn should have been on Second Chances, this was a chance to correct a mistake, but unfortunately Survivor is to blind to see that they had 3 other bad ass women over Hali. I just love Sarah and would have liked to see her back. If they wanted a girl who was young and had a kick ass body then bring back Chelsea Meissner. She mad better TV over Hali and she learned from one of the Best Kim Spradlin. I will even give you someone who wasn't on the list. Bring back RC Saint-Amor. RC would have been a great addition to the cast.
My problem with Troyzan:
I do not want to see Troyan play again. You had Marty Piombo. Besides the fact Nicaragua is running low on returning players, I believe Marty could have had a shot at winning this season. I see no way that Troyzan wins the season. Maybe that had a bad taste of Nicaragua still, then bring back LJ McKanas. Bring back the horse whisperer. He was a leader on his originally tribe and if he wasn't playing with one of the best winners then he may have won the season. Maybe Survivor thought they had to many Cagayan players, then bring back Jonathan Penner. I would love to see Jonathan Penner be a 4-time player, even though I think his Philippines exit was a great exit and a good way to end his story, Penner is a great character. We don't even have to go to the older side, bring back Jon Misch. Jon Misch, just like Natalie Bolton, should have been on the Second Chance ballot. Bring Jon back.
Pre Jurors:
Caleb Reynolds, Jeff Varner, and So Kim I am okay with seeing return
My problem with Alexis Maxwell:
I feel like with CBS they are trying to bring back a Kelly Wentworth type of player, but I would prefer to see Kelly back. I have seen Cagayan twice so I don't have a great memory, but from my memory she wasn't great. Bring back Kelly Czarnecki, bring back Rachel Fowler, bring back Stephanie Valencia, bring back Tracy Hughes-Wolf. Hell even from her own season, Bring Back J'Tia.
My problem with Brad Culpepper:
Fuck you Brad Culpepper. He wasn't even on the original list of 40, his wife was. I just don't like you. He was not voted into second chances for a reason CBS. He should not play again. There are so many other male pre-jurors you could have brought back. Bring back Aaron Reisberger, bring back Drew Christy, bring back Hunter Ellis, bring back Spencer Duhm, bring back Vince Sly.
My problem with Gretchen:
I get that CBS may be wanting to hit that Borneo contestant, but there are other season that are in need of some love. Africa, Marquesas, Thailand (especially Thailand), The Amazon, Vanuatu. The early season that don't have many returnees. I wouldn't mind seeing her play again, but I feel the only reason she is getting this is because she was from Borneo. Also she wasn't on the original list of 40.
Y