#1
- Tina Wesson (All-Stars)
- Jonny Fairplay (Micronesia)
- Nadiya Anderson (San Juan del Sur)
- Diane Ogden (Africa)
- Jonathan Libby (Palau)
- Rachel Ako (Millennials vs. Gen X)
- Kourtney Moon (One World)
- Jim Lynch (Guatemala)
- Ciera Eastin (Game Changers)
- Katrina Radke (Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers)
#2
- Nicole Delma (Pearl Islands)
- Sonja Christopher (Borneo)
- Darnell Hamilton (Kaoh Rong)
- Marisa Calihan (Samoa)
- Stephanie Gonzalez (Ghost Island)
- Mellisa McNulty (Fiji)
- So Kim (Worlds Apart)
- Ryan Aiken (The Amazon)
- Semhar Tadesse (South Pacific)
- Debb Eaton (The Australian Outback)
#3
- Francesca Hogi (Redemption Island and Caramoan)
- Vytas Baskauskas (Cambodia)
- Pat Cusack (David vs. Goliath)
- Tina Scheer (Panama)
- Rupert Boneham (Blood vs. Water)
- Jessica deBen (Fiji)
- Peter Harkey (Marquesas)
- Carolina Eastwood (Tocantins)
- Sugar Kiper (Heroes vs. Villains)
- Michelle Chase (Gabon)