Only from top 14 onward, and only counting competitive performances.
10. Dennis Lorenzo - "This Woman's Work"
9. Catie Turner - "Once Upon a Dream"
8. Michael J. Woodard - "Titanium"
7. Maddie Poppe - "Landslide"
6. Michael J. Woodard - "Beauty & The Beast"
5. Gabby Barrett - "I Have Nothing"
4. Maddie Poppe - "God Only Knows"
3. Gabby Barrett - "How Come You Don't Call Me Anymore?"
2. Maddie Poppe - "Nothing Compares 2 U"
1. Catie Turner - "Havana"