Okay...so for casting season 40...I really think the produces and Jeff at large need to consider the different archetypes...and trying to make sure each archetype is included in the series.
So first off….let’s start with all winners. Also...I am going to say we should secure one spot for the winner of this season. I say it will be either Lauren/Victoria/Julie. I really do not think a man is winning this season.
That leaves us with 14 winners over the course of the first 37 seasons. Without further adieu...here is each of them listed.
Tina
Vecepia
Jenna
Sandra x2
Amber
Danni
Parvati
Natalie W
Sophie
Kim
Denise
Natalie A
Michele
Sarah
So of these 14 winners...I think first we need to secure a few spots for our most legendary winners…..I think IF THEY WANNA COME BACK….PARVATI/KIM/SANDRA have their spots secured. Now lets see where we are at
CAST: (4/10)
-Kim
-Sandra
-Parvati
-S38 winner
(11/14)
Tina
Vecepia
Jenna
Amber
Danni
Natalie W
Sophie
Denise
Natalie A
Michele
Sarah
Now we are left with the remaining 11 winners vying for 6 spots remaining. I think from here...we need to first look at the recency effect. We have Michele/Natalie A/Sarah. In terms of giving us winners that the newer audience can recognize...I think Natalie A and Sarah are both shoe ins. Michele for now is going to remain uncasted. Now we have
CAST (6/10)
-Kim
-Sandra
-Parvati
-S38 winner
-Sarah
-Natalie A
This leaves us with the following people listed below.
(9/14)
Tina
Vecepia
Jenna
Amber
Danni
Natalie W
Sophie
Denise
Michele
Now we have the 9 of these contestants competing for 4 more spots. In terms of age/old school player vibes….I think Tina/Vecepia/Denise are all vying for the “old school” person spot. I know Denise didn’t play during old school era...but I think her and Tina are similar. And I think Vecepia game was too utr. So I would say Denise will probably be the one the contestants pick. Now we can leave Tina/Vecepia in limbo for now.
Below is the current remaining casting pool. I am automatically going to cut Jenna from the casting now due to her rough last few years. (Got arrested for DUI, etc)
(8/14)
Tina LIMBO
Vecepia LIMBO
Jenna LIMBO
Amber
Danni
Natalie W
Sophie
Michele LIMBO
Now we have 8 contestants still in the casting pool. I think the last archetype we need is UTR winner/bikini babe. Obviously these people are older now...but still similar appearance. I think Natalie W/Danni/Amber/Michele are all competing for 2 spots. I think Natalie W will get one spot for being a dark horse...and I think Amber will get the other spot. I am one of the few who think her and Rob playing together is a total option.
CAST (9/10)
-Kim
-Sandra
-Parvati
-S38 winner
-Sarah
-Natalie A
-Denise
-Amber
-Natalie W
NOW BELOW IS THE ONLY CONTESTANTS STILL IN THE CASTING POOL. ONE OF THEM NEEDS TO BE CAST
(6/14)
Tina LIMBO
Vecepia LIMBO
Jenna OUT
Danni LIMO
Sophie
Michele LIMBO
Regarding these 5 people still in contention...I honestly don’t know which one they will pick….but I am thinking for OG sentiment they will double up on the OG Mom archetype...and cast Tina. Not saying I agree...but It is what it is.
In turn...I predict the 10 female winners we get to be these below
CAST (10/10)
-Kim
-Sandra
-Parvati
-S38 winner
-Sarah
-Natalie A
-Denise
-Amber
-Natalie W
-Tina
Amber and Rob were asked if they wanted to come back for Blood vs Water, but they both declined saying
"We believe our survivor journey is over" or something like that. I also think Vecipia has no chance, as Jeff said he hated her- and Jenna out for the reasons you said. Also, for all we know season 40 might not even be an all winners season, as Jeff also said that an all winners season would be "Impossible, but I wouldn't rule any ideas out
