This matchup just would be so silly to watch: A doll vs a goat. I can see either winning, but if Chucky was able to sneak up to Black Philip and kill the goat then Chucky would win. However, Black Phillip is the literal devil and would be able to sense Chucky. I could see Black Phillip offering a deal to Chucky, however there isn’t much Chucky would actually like. Black Phillip also has a coven of witches who would probably just burn the doll in a fire, so I’d have to give this to Black Phillip.
Jungle Predator vs Amanda Young
Both are stealth killers, however Jungle Predator is probably the most stealthy of all the killers, being able to turn invisible and fire plasma bolts using the plasma cannon attached to their shoulder. I don’t think Amanda stands a chance.
Wolf Mask vs Kayako
This is another easy fight. A decent stealth human killer like Wolf Mask vs a Japanese ghost. If the Wolf Mask went into the house to face Kayako I think the Wolf Mask killer wouldn’t stand a chance.
Art The Clown vs Tethered
Art The Clown vs a tethered version of himself. I’m gonna be honest, Art is a psychotic killer and I think versing a version of himself that wants to be free and is more desperate, I see Art getting the upper hand and just, mutilating his tethered version.
Pinhead vs Bughuul
A cenobite vs a demon who uses children to kill. I think Pinhead would win just based on that Bughuul himself cannot kill unless there is a child, which Pinhead has no children. Pinhead however can kill, which leaves him as the winner of this matchup.
Norman Bates vs Asami
Norman has DID and Asami is a psychotic killer who becomes obsessed with men, so I feel like Asami definitely has the upper hands in this matchup.
Jason Voorhees vs Invisible Man
Jason is an undead silent but deadly killer and the Invisible Man is, well, invisible. I feel like although the Invisible Man has the upper hand, he couldn’t wear clothes, shoes or hold anything without being seen. I don’t think Invisible can hide forever and Jason would get him and just murder the hell outta him. Jason would win in this battle.
Pennywise vs Patrick Bateman
Lastly we have Pennywise and Patrick Bateman. I honestly see this being an entertaining battle with Pennywise turning into something gross to make Patrick uncomfortable. I see Patrick dying in this matchup though, as an axe and his smarts won’t be able to counter Pennywise.
The last 16 villains will now face off in 8 matchups. The matchups done by random.org are:
Baby Firefly 🪰 vs Samara 📼
Candyman 🐝 vs Ghostface ☎️
Leatherface 🪝vs Sack Face 🚪
Michael Myers 👨🔧 vs Undead Redneck Family 🧟♂️
Dracula 🧛🏻♂️ vs Freddy Kruger 😴
Jack Torrence ✍️ vs Xenomorph 👽
Carrie 🧠 vs Pazuzu 🤮
The Thing 🦹♂️ vs Valak ⛪️
This is who you’d think would win in a fight between the two villains. Not who is your favourite.
Some notes:
•Baby Firefly is from House of 1000 Corpses
•Sack Face is from The Strangers
•Undead Redneck Family is from Cabin In The Woods
•Freddy can bring people to his dream realm
•The Thing needs to assimilate people and can only be killed by fire/explosions.
Give me details on how you see each villain winning! I’d love to hear your scenarios!
