Now, I can explain my choices. I am not choosing players to return for a 3rd or 4th time.
EDIT : I'm bringing back 1 girl and 1 guy from every season. So that's why I have people like Kristen instead of Hayden.
BB8:
Eric Stein : This guy definitely deserves a second chance after his game was run by America. I think he has the potential to do very amazing on his own.
Jen Johnson : Jen was chosen purely because she was entertainment. She made it somewhat far, and being that the other females in BB8, (Amber, Jameka, Kail, etc) didn't amount to much, or they became a BB Legend, (Daniele) Jen is the only option remaining.
BB9:
Sheila Kennedy : Sheila played a fantastic game. She never floated and she won competitions when she needed to. She was able to divert drama away from herself, (the 'lesbians with Allison incident.') She was robbed at 3rd, and I think she is definitely All-Star Material.
James Zinkand : He was a complete competition BEAST. The house-guests brought him BACK INTO THE HOUSE after they JUST EVICTED him. He won America's Favorite Houseguest, and he is also All-Star Material.
BB10:
Libra Thompson : Libra RAN THE ENTIRE HOUSE before she was evicted. She controlled Nom-Sets, Evictions, she was amazing. Her only downfall was her ability to argue. (Is that a negative trait, though?) She made jury, and I believe she was All-Star Material.
Memphis Garrett : Memphis was runner-up to BB Legend Dan. I believe Memphis doesn't get enough credit, because after all, he was runner-up to Dan. He is constantly in his shadow. I believe Memphis deserves another round in the BB House, to prove he is an All-Star.
BB11:
Kevin Campbell : Kevin played an amazing social game. Everyone enjoyed his company, (besides Braden,) and he was robbed towards the very end of the game. I think Kevin was one of the only people to give Jordan a run for her money.
Michele Noonan : Michele was chosen because of who she is now, and who she was then. Michele has done a complete 180 with her personality, and I'd love to see her back. She also didn't do too shabby in BB11.
BB12 :
Matt Hoffman : Although I didn't enjoy watching Matt play, I must give credit where credit is due. Matt played a great strategic, physical, and social game. He is All-Star Material.
Kristen Bitting : Kristen was chosen for a similar reason why Jen was chosen. Entertainment. Britney and Rachel, (also from BB12) have run their course, and Kristen was the next best thing.
BB13:
Kalia Booker : Kalia won two HoH's and partnered up with Daniele Donato, while everyone else was against her. Kalia was robbed, and therefore, deserves to be brought back in Big Brother All-Stars.
Dominic Briones : Being that BB13 was a returning players season, I am only choosing from the newbies. Dominic was robbed, and I believe he has the ability to become an All-Star.
BB14:
Frank Eudy : Frank was a competition BEAST. The entire house was against him constantly, (Similar to BB9 James) and he should be brought back for similar reasons.
Danielle Murphey : This was a tough one. I fought between choosing Jenn Arroyo and Danielle. Jenn arguably played a better game, but Danielle made it farther. She also took part in a showmance, and I believe she was more memorable.
BB15 :
Helen Kim : Helen ran the house, up until she was evicted. She won a few competitions, and was the only one who could give Amanda a run for her money, (while she was still in the house.)
McCrae Olson : McCrae was fierce in competitions, and was memorable for being in a showmance with Amanda. He arguably played the best game, (for a male in his season) and I believe he is All-Star Material.
why in the hell did you take dan off the list he was there earlier. Definitely needs to be there instead of libra and memphis lol. More like Keesha and Dan!
For season 9, I would have taken Natalie over Sheila. For season 8, I would have chose Jameka over Jen. For 11, I would have actually taken Laura over Michele. Didn't like Michele that much. And for 13, I would have taken Shelley over Kalia and Adam over Dominic. All the others, I completely agree with.
Now, I can explain my choices. I am not choosing players to return for a 3rd or 4th time.