Do you thinks it's fair to allow a player on a secret redemption island to hand off an idol that THEY WERE VOTED OFF WITH to pass it off to a different player on RI and that different player returns at Final 5 and uses the idol?
depends...did they have it on them when they went to redemption island or find it on the island??? If they took it with them and passed it to someone directly on the island and can see that being ok...Same with if they found it on the island and left it on the island for the other person and didn't have it on their person when they left...If they were allowed to pass it after leaving the game completely then no that isn't cool...
I say they can only pass the idol before a RI challenge for example if player A. has an idol and loses a duel right before he leaves he cant give it to player B. but player A. can give it to him before a duel
In addition to what Kaitx said,
It wasn't secret though we all knew redemption island was in play
Nathan also said he had an idol and that was supposed to be common knowledge man.
I think the problem with it being a "secret" tribal is that we would have seen it happen irl if it happened in the middle of a duel. This isn't irl though and idols can be passed secretly through mail, not physically.
that's my problem. It was apparently passed through in the challenge. Yeah teamjacz I knew Nathan had the idol. And had i known he was allowed to pass the idol on RI then I would have made sure it was flushed rather than blindsiding him lol
BUT IN THE RULES BEFORE THE GAME STARTED THERE WAS NOTHING ABOUT IT BEING ALLOWED TO BE PASSED ON RI. HAD THERE BEEN I WOULD HAVE FLUSHED IT, NOT BLINDSIDED HIM. THAT WOULD BE DUMB OF US TBH
shut up imgonnawin you only made finals because of a fluke. You didn't even play the best game, you were voted out and only made final 3 because of and idol being able to be transferred to you WHILE on RI which is complete bullshit. Anybody that justifies that as a good game is literally stupid af.
After the games I'm in and the one I'm hosting I'm quitting tengaged again. This is why i left to begin with. Production teams on here are so stupid in their decision making process.
Also, what makes matters worst is if the idol was transferred AFTER THE DUEL started. So I would like to see and make sure it wasn't transferred during the duel btw thesexiestdude990
Umm I blindsided 5 jurors and 1 of them was you . Your lit the only who sa i I didn't play a good game . The idol.was handed to me in the middle ofnthe duel
I know this is late but in my opinion, if redemption island is a part of he game and once u get voted out of the tribe you go there, you aren't officially out of BE game, therefore yes you can still have an idol and pass it off like u would on a regular tribe in a regular game. The game isn't over until you're officially eliminated, not just voted out of a tribe. If the twist is redemption, then it's still a part of the game and can still do the use of idols.
Would I be pissed if I went home final 5 over someone with an idol?
Hell yes, but redemption was the twist and it's the way it has to work.
