Back from the challenge, the two main alliances met up once again to decide who to vote off. The alliance of Vanellope, Penny, Nani and Dory got together and all of them wanted to get rid of Robin Hood because of how strong he is and also how cunning he is. Once again they approached Nala with their plan and she was hesitant but agreed. The alliance of Robin Hood, Violet, Tiana and Donald talked in private and eventually came to a consensus to vote for Penny because of how well she was doing in the game. They also decided to let Nala in on the plan in order to have five votes and the majority. Nala was once again relieved that she would be surviving another vote with both alliances targeting each other, but now who is she to vote with? She knows she is an outsider to both alliances so deciding who to vote with is pretty difficult. But in the end she made her decision. At tribal council by a vote of 5-4 Penny became the 25th person voted out of Survivor All Stars and the fifth member of the jury.