Two episodes into the season, and my opinion of it is rather middling. I do find the cast moderately enjoyable, but they admittedly pale in comparison to the eclectic cast we got from Survivor: David vs. Goliath. Similar to Redemption Island, my opinion of Extinction Island is rather negative, since overall I don't like twists that brings eliminated contestants back into the game. One positive of this season is Jeff is as enjoyable of a host as ever, and the returnees they cast are at least quite different and fun.
So overall, I'd give this season a 5/10 in reference to my enjoyment of it so far. I hope in the coming weeks, it surprises me and raises its rating.
I also want to hear what you guys think of the season in the comments. If you post your opinion, I'll tag you in this blog.